SO YOU'RE TELLING ME YOU DRINK WATER FROM A GLASS / THEN USE CLEAN WATER TO WASH THE GLASS AFTER YOU DUMP WHAT YOU DIDN'T DRINK?
A So You're Telling me meme.
So You're Telling Me uses Jim Carrey as Lloyd Christmas in Dumb and Dumber (1994). When told his chances with the girl are one in a million, Lloyd lights up: "So you're telling me there's a chance!" Captions start with the bad odds and end with unshakable optimism. It's the meme for blind hope and hearing only what you want to hear.